Movies Ruined
DH and I watched The Punisher last night - a movie from 2004 starring Thomas Jane and John Travolta based on the comic book series. I'd never seen it before, didn't have a clue what it was about. Anyway, we sat down, the movie starts...for those of you who haven't seen it, the hero is an undercover FBI agent and in the opening scene an arms-smuggling bust goes down and he's shot and presumably killed. Turns out, he wasn't, his death was faked, and he's retiring from undercover work and moving his family to London where he's planning to take a safe desk job and finally be a family man. Hooked me right away. I thought, cool opening. John Travolta is the twisted father of one of the men killed in that bust, and he's out for revenge, tracks down Jane and vows to avenge his son's death.
So the movie starts, the hero goes home, is all lovey-dovey with his wife and son and tells them this time, their life will be different. DH and I are watching, and I say to him, "Oh, you just know the wife and kid are going to get whacked. The title The Punisher tells you all you need to know. He's got to be out for revenge." And DH (who also knew nothing about this movie) says, "No, Travolta's out for revenge. They wouldn't kill the wife and kid like that." Guess who was right? Me! (Of course).
I find this happens more and more as I write suspense. Movie twists are ruined for me because as I'm watching, I'm looking for the twists you wouldn't expect or that one element that haunts a character and gives them the motivation they need. In a movie - like this one - they generally show that defining moment, and it usually happens at the beginning of the film. But in books, that tortured backstory is woven through the story and revealed piece by piece, adding, in my opinion, more suspense and drama.
The Punisher went downhill from there. Lots of fighting and gruesome details, but then that's what the comic book was all about. I still think the opening was great though...the story could have gone in any direction from that point.
Do you find yourself looking for twists in movies? Or are you able to watch them without anticipating what will happen next?
So the movie starts, the hero goes home, is all lovey-dovey with his wife and son and tells them this time, their life will be different. DH and I are watching, and I say to him, "Oh, you just know the wife and kid are going to get whacked. The title The Punisher tells you all you need to know. He's got to be out for revenge." And DH (who also knew nothing about this movie) says, "No, Travolta's out for revenge. They wouldn't kill the wife and kid like that." Guess who was right? Me! (Of course).
I find this happens more and more as I write suspense. Movie twists are ruined for me because as I'm watching, I'm looking for the twists you wouldn't expect or that one element that haunts a character and gives them the motivation they need. In a movie - like this one - they generally show that defining moment, and it usually happens at the beginning of the film. But in books, that tortured backstory is woven through the story and revealed piece by piece, adding, in my opinion, more suspense and drama.
The Punisher went downhill from there. Lots of fighting and gruesome details, but then that's what the comic book was all about. I still think the opening was great though...the story could have gone in any direction from that point.
Do you find yourself looking for twists in movies? Or are you able to watch them without anticipating what will happen next?
Labels: Entertainment
10Comments:
I definitely find myself looking for twists, and it ruins a lot of movies for me. Worse, my oldest son is now doing the same thing. LOL We have a game we play where we see who can figure out what's going to happen first. My other two children really don't find this very amusing. *g*
I absolutely can't watch a movie without anticipating twists. But it doesn't ruin the show for me. It's more of a "can't wait to see how he handles that" kind of thing. When it's done in an ordinary way, i'm disappointed. When it's done creatively, I'm pleased.
After all, there are only so many plots, right? It's all about the creative execution.
This happens to me all the time. Not only in movies, in books too. I start reading, and the first chapter, I'll know who the killer is. I haven't kept track, but I'm right about 98% of the time. I love it when a book or movie surprises me. And when there are no surprises, it does tarnish it for me.
ROFL, Elisa. How old is your oldest?
True, J. It is all about the creative execution. That's why we read the same sort of plots over and over.
Wow, you're good, Edie!
Elisabeth--he's 12, and will be turning the dreaded 13 in May.
Elisabeth:
I ruin every movie for myself. My husband HATES me. I figured out Crying Game (Adam's apple, come on!). Sixth Sense. Whatever. Just find I think like a writer and anticipate it all. I nearly always know whodunnit. I can't help it!
:-)
E
I do usually work it out, but it doesn't ruin it for me unless the way I imagined it is better than the way it is actually done. I love it when they set something up and do justice to it.
I didn't guess the Sixth Sense end. Erica is better at this than I am.*g*
Post a Comment
<< Home